Whenever someone mentions semantics, the following scene from one of my favourite movies, Grosse Pointe Blank, plays in my head. Martin has just ordered an egg-white omelette at a diner…
Waitress: What do you want in your omelette, sir?
Martin: Nothing in the omelette, nothing at all.
Waitress: Well, that’s not technically an omelette.
Martin: Look, I don’t want to get into a semantic argument, I just want the protein.
Recently, I wrote about the difference between diction and syntax. Today, we’re going to look at the difference between semantics and pragmatics, two sides of a linguistic coin.
Semantics is the branch of linguistics concerned with the meaning of words and their meaning within sentences. Pragmatics looks at the same words and their meaning, but pragmatics also considers context. Consider the following sentence:
- Calliope saw the tear.
So was someone crying or did something rip? Semantics can tell us that a person named Calliope was looking at one or the other. Pragmatics goes a step further by looking at what else surrounds those words. If you are in the same place as Calliope, you would hear the difference in the way tear was pronounced—and you might see the same thing she does. If you are reading about it, then the context has likely been set for you. For example:
- Maximilian turned his head away, but not fast enough. Calliope saw the tear.
- Deirdre stood in front of the space-time continuum, but it was no use. Calliope saw the tear.
For most of us, semantics and pragmatics are instinctive. We process the conversations we hear and the words we read automatically. But we usually notice when the meaning isn’t clear, which can be the result of a poorly worded sentence, an ambiguous word choice, or unclear context. Headlines are usually the worst culprits. Here are some fun examples:
- Man helps werewolf bite victims.
- Kids make nutritious snacks.
- Sexist toys protest.
And for people learning a new language, semantics without pragmatics can lead to all kinds of confusion, especially when using idioms. For example, telling someone who is learning English to break a leg might get you in all kinds of trouble. So be sure to keep your audience in mind when choosing words and phrasing.
Image credit: Olga Sapegina / PhotoXpress.com
14 thoughts on “Semantics vs. Pragmatics”
I enjoy words so much that I wish there was a job where I could paid just to debate semantics 🙂
Seriously. That would be a pretty awesome job! 😀
Yeah, seems so!
Dear Suzanne,i am Hai, a student of the university of Adelaide. I would like to cite the definition of semantics and pragsmatics. Please can I have your full name?
Thank you in advance
Thanks for your message, Hai! My full name is Suzanne Purkis.
Alrighty! Here’s what you get when you send me down the “Grosse Point Blank” memory lane for the last 45 minutes of my life……http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119229/quotes. Enjoy all the best lines from one of the best movies ever!!!
LOL! No wonder we get along so well. 🙂
I still have the soundtrack on my favourites playlist. Such a great movie!
I enjoy your post’s mostly because I am pretty sure I murder English.
Calliope saw the tear.
He whispered as he handed her a tiny saw. That is what I visualized and put into the missing context. Did not even think of ripping or holes.
You’ve written about diction vs. syntax and semantics vs. pragmatics, but I’m confused about diction vs. semantics. If I criticize someone for using the wrong word in a statement (or for using a word incorrectly), am I criticizing her diction or her semantics?
If she mistakenly uses the wrong word, you would actually be criticizing her vocabulary. However, if she deliberately uses a word that you think is wrong, but she believes is right, you would be criticizing (or disagreeing with) her diction. Semantics is more focused on the study of meaning, whereas diction focuses on how people use language.
I hope that helps to answer your question. 🙂
waaaoh! I found it so helpful. I’m in Tanzania and I’m taking Linguistics course at the University of Dar es Salaam.
Thanks for the insights.I need related materials for my mphil/phd degrees, can you be of help ma?